Dollhouse Closed

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Dollhouse Closed

I know I'm asking for the inevitable backlash, but I'm just gonna say it.

Dollhouse sorta deserved it.

And this is coming from a diehard Browncoat and Whedon fan.

But, let's be real a sec. This wasn't the "Fox curse". Fox actually gave Dollhouse more of a shot than I believe it deserved -- likely BECAUSE of the Firefly cancellation backlash and resulting popularity if the series.

Personally, I stopped watching the show during the first season for one reason. I think Joss copped out and shifted his show focus because of the way the early episodes were received and out of fear that the show would get axed before it ever got off the ground.

When I first started watching, Dollhouse felt...uncomfortable as a concept. Here was this world in which people were property. Willingly (or for their own reasons) giving up their identities to become a company asset and used for whatever purpose the company deigned necessary without having to deal with any residual guilt or memory of the event.

People being used for whatever purpose, with no memory or guilt -- and a company profits. Experimentation without limit, on human beings and it's just a day to day occurrence.

Now, that was interesting to me. Orwellian and thought provoking and, like those of us that saw the dismantling of Summer Tam as something a government would do if they could -- grossly fascinating.

But, in my opinion, the show shifted focus and I lost interest. It stopped feeling creepy and just started feeling like another week of "Here goes Eliza and what is she wearing this week."

But that can get old. Quickly. And once you've seen one episode and you know how it goes, why do you come back to watch again?

Go watch "Once More With Feeling" and ask yourself if Echo ever touched you anywhere near as deeply as Buffy did discussing something as out there as being pulled back from Heaven for the (second, third, fourth I forget?) time?

Joss works best when he has his characters dealing with the repercussions of their actions, even when the circumstances are utterly out there.

When you hold Dollhouse up to that standard, does it really measure up?

8 comments:

  1. I agree completely and you've said it much more eloquently than I could.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If the reviews (and opinions of like-minded peers) had been kinder I would have watched. They weren't so I didn't.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Just so you know you're not alone out there, I agree (though some friends tried to tell me season 2 got better, but I never gave it another shot.) So now you have at least one blade of armor between you and the backlash :P

    ReplyDelete
  4. You know, Echo never touched me that deeply, but Priya/Sierra and Topher have, which says something given that we'd had 6 seasons with Buffy before we had that touching moment.

    It was tricky to navigate, but honestly, I always looked forward to Dollhouse because it had profound things to say. Dollhouse shines most when it rests on the shoulders of its ensemble more so than its star, which is unfortunate insomuch as the series was created as a vehicle for Eliza Dushku.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Alas, this is sad but not wholly unsuspecting bit of news. I think it's time to focus more on Dr. Horrible and the advent of a new media leg. Wishing the best for Joss and Company!

    ReplyDelete
  6. but what you wanted to happen DID happen in season 2! dolls realized who they were. memories surfaced.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wasn't hugely impressed with Dollhouse. I've only seen a few episodes. But, I wasn't overwhelmingly impressed with Buffy either. Never liked Buffy as a character until way into the many seasons - I only watched it because my boyfriend read Harry Potter for me in exchange. To me, Joss's only great show was Firefly.

    ReplyDelete
  8. ... there was a person named Echo in Dollhouse? But, her name is my name too! Whenever we go out.....

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...